Your Next Ride: Kelley Blue Book's Best Used Car Picks
Description
Best used cars offer incredible value compared to buying new, and the data backs this up. With new car prices still near record highs and used car interest rates typically ranging from 6-12% compared to 0-5% for new cars, smart buyers are turning to the pre-owned market for better deals.
Top Categories of Best Used Cars:
- Under $15,000: Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, Hyundai Elantra
- SUVs Under $20,000: Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, Subaru Outback
- Trucks Under $30,000: Ford F-150, Ram 1500, Toyota Tacoma
- Most Reliable Brands: Toyota, Honda, Mazda, Subaru, Lexus
The numbers tell the story. New cars lose about 60% of their value in the first five years, while a well-chosen used car has already taken that depreciation hit. You get more car for your money, lower insurance costs, and proven reliability when you buy smart.
Consumer Reports data shows that brands like Toyota, Honda, and Mazda consistently rank highest for used car reliability. Models like the Honda CR-V, Toyota Camry, and Mazda CX-5 regularly appear on "best used car" lists because they combine dependability with strong resale values.
But here's what many buyers don't realize: finding the right used car isn't just about the model - it's about the individual vehicle's history, condition, and how well it fits your budget and needs.
Our Picks: Top Used Cars for Every Budget
Finding the best used cars isn't about picking the shiniest one on the lot. It's about finding vehicles that deliver real value – cars that won't leave you stranded or drain your bank account with repairs. We've spent years helping Utah families find reliable rides, and we've noticed some clear winners across every budget range.
Whether you're stretching every dollar, need room for the whole family, or require serious hauling power, there's a fantastic used car waiting for you. Let's explore our top picks that consistently make our customers happy.
Best Used Cars Under $15,000
Getting a solid car for under fifteen grand is absolutely doable when you know what to look for. The secret is focusing on models known for their fuel efficiency and low maintenance costs – cars that keep saving you money long after you drive them home.
The Honda Civic tops our list for being nearly bulletproof. It's known for excellent fuel economy, readily available parts, and an enjoyable driving experience, making it a smart and fun choice.
The Toyota Corolla is the definition of reliability. Famous for easily reaching 200,000 miles and beyond, it's the perfect car for anyone who values dependability above all else.
For drivers who want more personality, the Mazda3 offers a winning combination of style, reliability, and driving enjoyment. It proves that an affordable car can still be fun and dependable.
The Hyundai Elantra delivers impressive value. It often comes loaded with features that are optional on other brands, offering a comfortable, efficient, and well-equipped ride for less.
These aren't just cheap cars – they're smart investments that happen to be affordable. More info about our affordable cars
Best Used SUVs Under $20,000
SUVs have become America's favorite family vehicle, offering the versatility and cargo space that sedans can't match, plus many come with all-wheel drive for Utah's snowy winters.
The Honda CR-V is our top recommendation because it does everything well. It balances space and efficiency perfectly, boasts excellent safety ratings, and comes with Honda's legendary reliability.
Toyota's RAV4 offers Toyota's famous dependability in a versatile SUV package. It's built to last, holds its value well, and is often available with AWD for Utah's winters.
The Subaru Outback is perfect for adventurous families, with standard all-wheel drive for confidence on any road. It offers a comfortable ride and ample space for gear.
Don't overlook the Ford Escape – it's a practical, often-overlooked choice. It provides good tech features and fuel economy, delivering SUV utility without the high gas bills.
Best Used Trucks Under $30,000
When you need a truck, you need it to work. The good news is that thirty grand can still buy you serious towing capacity and proven durability in the used truck market.
The Ford F-150 has been America's bestselling truck for decades for one reason: it works. With various engines and configurations, a used F-150 delivers the capability you need for work or play without the new-truck price tag.
The Ram 1500 stands out with its comfortable, SUV-like ride, thanks to its unique coil-spring rear suspension. It delivers impressive towing power without the typically harsh truck ride.
The Toyota Tacoma is a mid-size truck with legendary reliability and outstanding resale value. It's perfect for those who need truck capability in a more manageable package.
Each of these trucks represents years of proven performance and the kind of durability that makes them smart long-term investments. See our used truck inventory
The Smart Buyer's Checklist: What to Look for in a Used Car
Buying a used car should be exciting, not stressful! Think of it as a treasure hunt where a little detective work up front can save you thousands down the road. A few extra steps now means you'll be driving away with complete confidence in your purchase.
Key Reliability Features
When you're hunting for the best used cars, reliability is everything. Here's what to pay attention to.
Engine performance is where it all starts. A healthy engine should run quietly without knocking or pinging, accelerate smoothly, and show no blue or white exhaust smoke.
The transmission type can make or break your ownership experience. The transmission should shift smoothly without jerking or slipping. Any hesitation can signal costly repairs, so pay close attention during the test drive.
Safety ratings from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) are crucial. Always check these ratings online to understand how a vehicle protects its occupants in a crash.
Many used cars now include advanced driver-assist systems like automatic emergency braking and blind-spot monitoring. Verify these safety features work correctly during your test drive.
Brands like Toyota, Honda, Mazda, and Lexus consistently top the reliability charts, a fact backed by studies from sources like Consumer Reports.
The Importance of a Vehicle History Report
A vehicle history report is a car's medical record and is crucial for making a smart purchase.
Accident history shows any reported crashes. Minor accidents can hide issues, while major ones could mean structural damage affecting safety.
The title status is critical. Avoid vehicles with salvage, flood, or rebuilt titles, as they often have hidden problems and are difficult to insure or resell.
Service records indicate how well the car was maintained. A history of regular oil changes and timely repairs is a strong sign of a reliable vehicle.
Odometer reading verification helps you avoid fraud. The report confirms the mileage is accurate and hasn't been rolled back by a dishonest seller.
At Peterson Auto Sales, transparency is how we do business. That's why we provide a free vehicle history report with every car at Peterson Auto Sales. No surprises, just the facts you need.
Why Buy from a Dealership?
While buying privately might seem cheaper, it comes with significant risks. When you buy from a reputable dealership like Peterson Auto Sales, you get benefits a private seller can't offer.
We provide thorough inspections by certified technicians, access to financing options for all credit situations, and available warranties for peace of mind. We handle all the paperwork and provide a transparent, direct negotiation process. As a Utah Quality Dealer of the Year award winner, our reputation is built on customer satisfaction.
| Feature | Reputable Dealership | Private Seller |
|---|---|---|
| Thorough Inspections | Multi-point inspections by certified technicians | "As-is" sales; buyer assumes all risk |
| Financing Options | Access to multiple lenders, bad credit options | Often cash-only; buyer secures own loan |
| Available Warranties | CPO programs, extended warranties, service contracts | Typically no warranty; no recourse |
| Peace of Mind | Established reputation, legal protections, customer service | Unknown history, limited legal recourse |
| Paperwork & Registration | Handled for you, proper transfer guaranteed | Buyer responsible for all paperwork |
Navigating the Financing and Purchase Process
You've found the perfect car from our selection of best used cars - now what? The financing and purchase process doesn't have to be overwhelming. With a little preparation, getting behind the wheel can be surprisingly straightforward.
When you know what you can afford and have your financing sorted out, you can focus on the excitement of your new purchase instead of stressing about the numbers. Get pre-approved for financing
Understanding Used Car Loans
Used car financing differs from new car financing. The 0% APR deals you see advertised are manufacturer incentives for new vehicles only. However, great financing is still available for used cars.
Interest rates for used vehicles are competitive. Your credit score is the biggest factor, but we work with a network of lenders to help buyers with all types of credit, including bad credit or limited credit.
Loan terms for used cars are generally shorter than new car loans, often ranging from 48 to 72 months. This means you'll pay less interest over the life of the loan. For newer used vehicles, longer terms are sometimes available.
Getting pre-approved for financing is one of the smartest moves you can make. You'll know exactly what you can afford, which makes the buying process faster and less stressful. It's like shopping with cash in your pocket! More info about our financing options
The Role of Warranties and Inspections
Protecting your investment with warranties and inspections is a smart move. This is where they become your best friends.
Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) programs offer excellent peace of mind. These vehicles undergo rigorous inspections and include manufacturer-backed warranties, making them worth the slightly higher cost for the added confidence.
For non-CPO cars, aftermarket warranties (or Vehicle Service Contracts) offer similar protection, covering specific repairs for a set time or mileage. We can help you find a plan that fits your needs.
Even with our thorough inspections, we encourage customers to get an independent mechanic inspection for an unbiased expert opinion on the vehicle's condition.
As a Utah dealership, we ensure every vehicle passes the Utah safety inspection requirements. This covers critical safety components, so you can drive off our lot knowing your car is safe and roadworthy.
The Best Used Cars of 2025: A Category Roundup
As we look ahead, certain models continue to stand out as the best used cars due to their consistent performance, reliability, and long-term value. These are the vehicles that consistently earn top ratings and deliver a fantastic ownership experience.
Top Picks for the Best Used Sedans
Sedans remain a popular choice for their comfort, fuel efficiency, and refined driving experience.
- Toyota Camry: The Camry is the benchmark for reliability. It's known for a comfortable ride, spacious interior, and strong resale value, making it a smart choice for a long-lasting, low-cost vehicle.
- Honda Accord: The Accord blends sporty handling with Honda's renowned reliability. It offers an engaging driving experience, excellent fuel economy, and a well-designed interior.
- Hyundai Sonata: The Sonata showcases Hyundai's modern change, offering stylish design, a comfortable cabin, and abundant features at a great price. Its improved reliability makes it a fantastic value.
Top Picks for the Best Used SUVs and Crossovers
SUVs and crossovers continue to dominate the market, offering the perfect blend of passenger comfort, cargo space, and versatility.
- Toyota Highlander: The Highlander is a top choice for families needing three rows and robust reliability. It provides a quiet, comfortable ride and Toyota's legendary dependability, with available AWD for all-weather capability.
- Honda CR-V: The CR-V is a standout in the compact SUV class. It's easy to drive, surprisingly spacious, and offers strong fuel economy and high safety ratings, making it a versatile family vehicle.
- Subaru Forester: With standard all-wheel drive and a spacious, boxy design, the Forester is perfect for outdoor trips and challenging weather. It's known for safety, utility, and a robust build.
Top Picks for the Best Used Trucks
Trucks are built for tough jobs, and certain models have proven their mettle over years of service.
- Ford F-150: The F-150 continues to be the undisputed king of trucks. Its variety of configurations, engine options, and trim levels means there's an F-150 for every need. Its durability and towing prowess make it an excellent used buy.
- Chevrolet Silverado: The Silverado is a powerful F-150 competitor, offering strong V8 engines and impressive towing capabilities. It's a rugged, dependable truck for both work and recreation.
When looking for a used truck, consider these key features:
- Towing Capacity: How much weight can it safely pull?
- Payload Capacity: How much weight can it carry in its bed and cabin?
- Bed Length: Do you need a short bed for maneuverability or a long bed for cargo?
- Engine Type: V6 or V8? Diesel or gasoline?
- Drivetrain: 2WD or 4x4? Crucial for off-road and adverse conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions about Buying Used Cars
Here are answers to the most common questions we receive about buying one of the best used cars.
How do interest rates for used cars compare to new cars?
Used car interest rates are typically slightly higher than new car rates because manufacturer-subsidized rates don't apply to pre-owned vehicles. Your final rate depends on your credit score, the vehicle's age, and the loan term. A strong credit score earns a lower rate. We work with a network of lenders to find competitive financing for all credit situations, including those with bad credit or no credit.
What is the importance of a warranty when buying a used car?
A warranty is a financial safety net against unexpected repairs. Even reliable used cars can have issues, and a warranty can save you from thousands in out-of-pocket costs for major components like the engine or transmission. Options include remaining manufacturer warranties on newer cars or dealership service contracts and extended warranties for older vehicles. This protection provides invaluable peace of mind, letting you enjoy your car without worrying about what might go wrong.
What are the most popular ways to shop for used cars?
Most car shopping now starts online. Dealership websites are the most popular starting point, allowing you to browse inventory, view photos, and see vehicle history reports from home. While online marketplaces exist, buying from a reputable dealership like Peterson Auto Sales offers key advantages private sellers can't match: professional inspections, diverse financing options, quality assurance, and buyer protection. We handle all the paperwork and stand behind every vehicle we sell, ensuring a transparent and trustworthy process. You can do your research online and visit us for a pressure-free test drive when you're ready.
Find Your Perfect Ride in Midvale, Utah
You're now equipped to find one of the best used cars that delivers value and reliability. By focusing on proven models, checking the vehicle history, and securing the right financing, you're making a smart investment. The peace of mind that comes from an informed purchase is priceless—knowing your vehicle is inspected, its history is transparent, and it fits your budget.
At Peterson Auto Sales, we're not just another dealership – we're a family-owned business right here in Midvale, Utah, and we're incredibly proud to be a Utah Quality Dealer of the Year award winner. What does that mean for you? It means we've earned our reputation by putting customers first, offering a genuinely low-pressure experience, and maintaining a wide selection of quality used cars and trucks that we'd be happy to put our own families in.
We believe everyone deserves a great car, regardless of their credit situation. That's why we've developed diverse financing options that work for people with bad credit, no credit, or anything in between. Our goal isn't just to make a sale – it's to start a relationship that lasts for years. When you're ready for your next vehicle, we want you to come back because you had such a positive experience the first time.
The road to finding your perfect ride doesn't have to be stressful. With the right dealership partner, it can be enjoyable. Come visit us in Midvale and let our friendly team help you find your next ride – we're confident you'll love both the car you drive home and the experience of finding it. Browse our inventory of used cars today!